On Saturday, January 31, 2026, YouTube India is witnessing one of its messiest “civil wars” in recent history. On one side is Thugesh (Mahesh Keshwala), one of India’s most beloved commentary and lifestyle creators, known for his clean image, relatable humor, and massive subscriber base (15M+). On the other side is Nishu Tiwari, a rising roaster and commentary channel known for his raw, aggressive, and often filter-free takedowns of internet celebrities.
What started as a minor disagreement has snowballed into a full-blown saga involving allegations of content theft, copyright abuse, and “God Complex” behavior. The feud has forced almost every major creator—from Neon Man to Lakshay Chaudhary—to pick a side.
The Origin: The “Exposed” Video
The spark that lit the fire was a video uploaded by Nishu Tiwari on January 25, 2026, titled “The Dark Side of Your Favorite Nice Guy.” In this 20-minute video, Nishu made some startling allegations against Thugesh.
- Script Theft: Nishu alleged that Thugesh’s recent series on “Tier 2 City Scams” was blatantly copied from a smaller creator with less than 50k subscribers. Nishu played side-by-side clips showing nearly identical dialogue and punchlines.
- The “Inspiration” Defense: Nishu argued that big creators like Thugesh hide behind the word “inspiration” to steal concepts from smaller creators who lack the resources to fight back.
- Hypocrisy: He called out Thugesh for preaching about “supporting small creators” in podcasts while allegedly crushing them behind the scenes.
The video went viral, garnering over 2 million views in 48 hours, threatening to dent Thugesh’s carefully curated “Good Boy” image.
The Retaliation: The Copyright Strike
Things turned ugly on January 28, when Nishu Tiwari took to Twitter (X) to reveal that his “Exposed” video had been taken down.
- The Strike: He shared a screenshot showing a Copyright Strike issued by his management agency.
- The Narrative: This move backfired spectacularly on Thugesh. In the world of YouTube, issuing a copyright strike to silence criticism is considered the ultimate sin. It is often viewed as an admission of guilt and an abuse of power.
- Nishu’s Rage: Nishu posted a furious video on his secondary channel, accusing Thugesh of trying to “eat” his career. “You can delete my video, but you can’t delete the truth,” Nishu declared, rallying the underground commentary community behind him.
Thugesh Breaks Silence: “It Was Defamation, Not Criticism”
After three days of silence and losing nearly 100,000 subscribers due to the backlash, Thugesh finally addressed the issue in a community post and an Instagram Live on January 30.
- The Defense: Thugesh claimed that the strike was not about silencing criticism but about defamation. He argued that Nishu used personal photos of his family and made baseless allegations about his financial dealings that crossed the line of “fair use.”
- The “Copy” Allegation: Regarding the script theft, Thugesh stated it was a coincidence. “Topics often overlap in the commentary genre. Two people can have the same thought about a scam,” he argued. He also offered to promote the smaller creator he was accused of copying to clear the air.
- The Apology: He admitted that the copyright strike was a “knee-jerk reaction” by his team and promised to retract it, provided Nishu blurred the personal details in a re-upload.
The Community Reacts: A Divided House
The feud has split the Indian creator economy into two distinct camps.
Team Nishu (The Underground): Smaller creators and roasters see Nishu as a martyr fighting against the “YouTube Mafia.”
- Creators like Danky Rishu and Priyal Dhuri have posted cryptic stories supporting the right to criticize.
- The argument is that big creators use strikes as a weapon to maintain their monopoly.
Team Thugesh (The Establishment): Mainstream creators feel Nishu went too far.
- Many point out that Nishu’s language is often abusive and that “roasting” shouldn’t involve dragging families into the mud.
- Supporters argue that Thugesh has a track record of being unproblematic for 5 years, and one coincidence shouldn’t ruin his career.
The “God Complex” of Big YouTubers
This controversy has sparked a broader debate about the “God Complex” among top-tier Indian YouTubers. Critics argue that once creators cross the 10-million subscriber mark, they become immune to feedback. They surround themselves with “Yes Men” (management agencies) who aggressively shut down dissent. Nishu Tiwari’s attack on Thugesh is seen by many as a necessary “reality check” for the elite tier of YouTube India.
Current Status (Jan 31, 2026)
As of today, the copyright strike against Nishu Tiwari has been retracted, and his video is back online (with minor edits). However, the damage is done.
- Thugesh is facing a wave of negative comments on his latest videos, with fans spanning the comment section with “L” (Loss) and “Chor” (Thief).
- Nishu Tiwari has gained 200,000 subscribers in a week, cementing his position as the new “Watchdog” of the community.
- The two have not spoken privately, and a “Diss Track” from Nishu is rumored to be in the works.
Verdict: Who Won?
In terms of public perception, Nishu Tiwari has emerged as the winner of this round. By forcing a giant like Thugesh to retract a strike, he has proven that the “David vs. Goliath” narrative still works on the internet. Thugesh, meanwhile, faces the difficult task of rebuilding trust. The incident serves as a stark reminder: On the internet, you are only as good as your last mistake.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Why are Thugesh and Nishu Tiwari fighting? The fight started when Nishu Tiwari uploaded a video accusing Thugesh of copying scripts from smaller creators. The situation escalated when Thugesh’s team issued a copyright strike against Nishu’s video.
2. Did Thugesh copy his content? Nishu Tiwari provided side-by-side clips showing similarities between Thugesh’s video and a smaller creator’s video. Thugesh has denied intentional copying, calling it a coincidence or “overlapping topics.”
3. Did Thugesh remove the copyright strike? Yes. Following massive backlash from the community, Thugesh announced on January 30 that he would retract the strike, admitting it was a harsh reaction.
4. Who is Nishu Tiwari? Nishu Tiwari is an Indian YouTuber known for his roasting and commentary videos. He is known for his aggressive style and for calling out popular influencers.
5. What is the subscriber difference between them? Thugesh has over 15 Million subscribers, while Nishu Tiwari (before this controversy) had around 600k-800k. The feud has significantly boosted Nishu’s numbers.
2 Comments
Get paid for every referral—enroll in our affiliate program!
Share our offers and watch your wallet grow—become an affiliate!